White Stripes>Jack White

[Duane]

a šta da okači Objectivity Commisons Approved Opinion On Current Subject? iliti OCAOOCS?

potpišite formular G32/L4 i možete izjaviti da je Pet Metini bolji gitarista od Džeka Vajta, ako i dalje stojite pri toj izjavi, a niste potpisali dotični dokument, biće te krivično gonjeni od strane Objektivne Komisije i Kombinata za Analitiku i Preradu Podataka.

Hvala na razumevanju, vaša Objektivna Policija

[KirilStipsa]

Tesla bi bio bolji gitarista od Pet Metinija... da je hteo da svira gitaru.

A Jack White je ok... al' malo dosadan.

[sinisake]

šonešone nešto nisi raspoložen lately?

Da, Sone se sad redje javlja, al' kad se javi, ne da ga nabode, nego samo tako...
Jos malo pa bi mog'o da se kandiduje za 'Pametna misao za danas'.

[Haralampije]

Dobar je Dzek Vajt,jako talentovan i darovit muzicar,ali za Alternativu ili Rock.

[whosyourdaddy]

evo Serdu za tebe, sve sto volis, fuzz-evi i rastimovane (kockaste) gitare i nigde mesa boogie i scala gitara!
The Dead Weather : 20 mins Live Set Performance mr. White na bubnjevima

[Randy]

ja slusam skoro sve zanrove muzike metal,blues,jazz,60s',.... ,a muziku delim na dobru i losu.pod dobru mislim na onu koja budi razlicita osecanja.moze da me razveseli neki metal solo od 15min ,a moze neki prosti blues.za stvaranje muzike je potrebna ljubav ,a ne sve skale sveta i svi akordi.pritom mislim da jack moze da stvori pesmu sa dva instrumenta i 3 akorda,a da bude masterpiece sto neki ne mogu ni sa celim orkestrom.dobar primer je knockin on heavens door od dilana.

[Funkomat]

The White Stripes su mi genijalni. Zvuk gitare, glas, bubnjevi, pesme, naziv benda... sve je genijalno. Savrsenstvo jednostavnosti.

[Bluesko]

biće te

[Dersu Uzala]

Back on topic:

"The latest fraud...This dog and pony show breathes new life into P.T. Barnum's observation that "there's a sucker born every minute." Would it be too much to ask that they transfer a little coin from their obviously lavish wardrobe budget into music lessons? A metronome, perhaps.

Grade school kids play better than this, but I suppose that's one more reason to love them in the minds of their faithful."


"After reading all of the reviews praising this group, I had to say something. This is quite possibly the WORST band I have ever heard in life. Jack White can't sing...well I wouldn't even classify it as singing. I'd compare his voice to a rusty bike tire....it's just annoying, plain and simple. And Meg White playing drums, I could make better sounds using bowls in my kitchen. The White Stripes are a disgrace to rock music everywhere. Everytime I see one of their videos played on MTV the same question pops into my head every single time 'Why God? Why?' So unless you are looking for a frisbee then don't buy this garbage, because that's basically all it's good for...garbage just shear garbage. "


"I have an unhealthy dislike for the White Stripes. I think they are awful and they represent everything that is wrong with music today-- i.e. talentless and nothing but image. There is really no distinction between the White stripes and Britney Spears in this regards-- neither is original, neither is talented, and both are nothing more than a superficial image. The White Stripes' melodies are simplistic and hackneyed; their lyrics are juvenille; and they are inept musicians-- especially the drummer. Their music is unoriginal and recycled. Beyond the music, their "schtick" is as annoying as their music: promoting the ambiguities about their past, their stupid white and red outfits, and their self-characterization as "minimalism", which is really just "code" for simplistic and talentless. I also think they are incredible hypocrits. For example, they always talk about how "alternative" they are and how "anti-mainstream" they are, yet there they are in Rolling Stone and Spin and on Jay Leno. The Strokes, the Vines, the Hives-- all of these bands suck-- but the White Stripes are the absolute worst. DON"T BELIEVE THE HYPE! "


"This band is horrible. I found no redeeming quality to it on a musical vein. All of the great albums you can listen to over and over again and discover new things because there are subtle layers and textures there. Here there is none. You can't get very complicated with a guitar and simple four piece drum set. The simple poppy hooks might be fine for someone with no real musical taste but when you listen to as many new releases as I do it get's very old, very quick. I wouldn't be surprised if this record will be mocked some day in the future as the downfall of the pop culture of the 90's to bring in a new genre for the 00's.

All in all "The White Stripes" are terribly overrated and in my opinion do not live up to the hype, they collapse and burn under the pressure. "


"A Disgrace to Real Musicians.............My goodness, if this could be considered music, then the whole world of music might as well come crashing down. Besides some melody hooks (that get old fast), the guitar riffs are repetitive and bland. Meg's drums are amateur and so incredibly simple that anyone playing for the first time could take her place. Sorry, but for any artistic potential, technical ability must be there and the White Stripes simply don't have it. Every song is the same, not one of them is redeemable. It's a shame that marketing has made this "band" so recognized while good bands like the Hellacopters are shoved to the background. This is proof that hype can be created even when good music is not. Please, for the sake of real musicians out there, don't buy into this hype."

[Duane]

jebiga, brate, greši čovek

[Bluesko]

Dersue bratue, ovakvih komada komentara ima milijardu i tristapedes hiljada i za Radiohead, Pink Floyd, The Clash, Betovena i MIlesa Davisa, `de god `oces....




So what!

[Dersu Uzala]

Drago mi je da se razumemo. Mislim, mogao sam ja da okacim i pozitivne komentare sa Amazona. Ali nisam.


Evo, zauzvrat, malo rokenrola kako dolikuje.

[nemanjavelimirovic]

Drago mi je da se razumemo. Mislim, mogao sam ja da okacim i pozitivne komentare sa Amazona. Ali nisam.


Evo, zauzvrat, malo rokenrola kako dolikuje.

ne zameri.. Al kad vidim Kiss odma padne

Eto tebi White Stripes izaziva a meni recimo ovo gore izaziva
no offence

[Dersu Uzala]

Zazmuri onda i samo slusaj.

[Bluesko]

Jos `ladno likovi popljuvali Strokese.... Ovo mora da je neki metal podforum